Public Radio for the Heart of Alabama
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations
Alexa Stream Issue: WBHM 90.3 and The Hub on 106.1 are temporarily unavailable. We’re working to resolve the issue. For now, try saying, “Alexa, play WBHM on TuneIn” to listen.

Central Alabama Water to settle lawsuit from ousted engineering firm that alleged unpaid bills

A man in a blue suit stands at a microphone and speaks to four men seated behind cloth-covered tables lined up at the front of a room. Behind them, an image of a dam is projected on a screen, along with the word "Agenda" and an outline of an update on a dam stability project.
Olivia McMurrey
/
BirminghamWatch
Patrick Flannelly, senior vice president of Arcadis U.S., gives a presentation to the CAW board in 2025 about the Lake Purdy Dam stabilization project.

Central Alabama Water will settle a lawsuit with the public utility’s longtime engineering advisor, which claimed CAW owed the firm more than a million dollars in unpaid bills.

Arcadis U.S. had provided guidance across the water system’s projects and operations for more than two decades. CAW’s board of directors voted to replace Arcadis late last year, after a state law restructured the board and the utility, which serves the greater Birmingham area. According to the lawsuit Arcadis filed in Jefferson County Circuit Court, CAW breached contracts by failing to pay $1.4 million for engineering services Arcadis performed before contracts officially ended in April.

Arcadis alleged that CAW illegally conditioned payment on Arcadis producing all its documents associated with CAW spanning the entire 22-year relationship.

“Over the course of Arcadis’s decades long relationship with CAW, Arcadis always provided CAW with final documentation of its services and engineering documents for all projects performed by it or others under its direction,” states the legal complaint Arcadis filed Sept. 15. “CAW cannot deny payment to Arcadis on a newly invented extra contractual desire that it receive ‘all’ documents again.”

The suit alleges CAW failed to retain its own records or was unwilling to search for them.

A slide presented during a CAW board meeting gives an overview of Arcadis as an international firm and lists credentials and contact information for its Birmingham-area team.
Olivia McMurrey
/
BirminghamWatch
Arcadis was among three companies that submitted proposals last year to serve as CAW's consulting engineer beginning in 2026. A slide presented during a CAW board meeting gives an overview of the international firm and its Birmingham-area team.

CAW’s board entered a private meeting Friday to discuss “legal matters,” then returned to a public session and voted to settle the lawsuit. Board members didn’t give the settlement amount.

After the meeting, a spokesperson for the utility did not respond to a question about the amount of the settlement.

“CAW doesn’t comment on pending litigation,” said John Matson, public relations manager for CAW.

In court filings, Arcadis requested approximately $1.4 million for work conducted in October 2025 through early 2026, plus interest on those funds.

In addition to the engineering-consulting contract that began in 2003 and renewed annually, CAW also terminated a 2024 contract with Arcadis to provide construction management services for a project to stabilize Lake Purdy Dam, which supports the drinking water supply for most of CAW’s residential customers.

CAW Chief Executive Jeffrey Thompson stopped that four-year project in January, after one year.

Last year, when CAW’s new board began questioning whether the $86 million project should move forward, Arcadis Senior Vice President Patrick Flannelly said in public meetings the dam wasn’t safe enough, based on widely accepted engineering standards, and its failure would threaten lives and homes in a 40-mile wave stream.

Arcadis asserted in the lawsuit that it performed all required engineering services, delivered all promised products and completed every duty its contracts with CAW required.

Olivia McMurrey's multimedia storytelling has encompassed a wide range of topics as well as local, regional and national perspectives. She has special interest in labor, economic, education and environmental reporting, and her work has won national and regional awards. Olivia earned a bachelor's degree in journalism and a master's degree in creative writing from the University of Alabama at Birmingham. She is a past president of Alabama Media Professionals and currently chairs the organization’s News Literacy Committee.

Got a story idea or tip for Olivia? Email [email protected].